Total Talent Acquisition: Can it bridge the Temp/Permanent Divide?

Total Talent Acquisition: Can it bridge the Temp/Permanent Divide?

As the demand for flexible workforces grows, Total Talent Acquisition (TTA) is emerging as a key strategy to bridge the divide between temporary and permanent recruitment. By combining these traditionally separate streams of talent acquisition, TTA gives organizations access to a more diverse and adaptable pool of talent, boosting agility, efficiency, and workforce readiness.

According to a 2023 survey by Staffing Industry Analysts (SIA), 42% of companies plan to explore TTA within the next two years, a response to the need for greater skill availability, improved workforce visibility, and better control of costs. Despite these advantages, adoption remains low, with only 16% of companies currently managing a TTA programme. Organizations face multiple challenges in fully realising the benefits of TTA, particularly around aligning contingent and permanent workforce management systems.

The Role of a Vendor Management System (VMS) in Total Talent Acquisition

A successful Total Talent Acquisition strategy requires the right technology, and this is where a Vendor Management System (VMS) can play a crucial role. A VMS enables centralized management of the contingent workforce, bringing streamlined processes, improved compliance, and greater visibility across all workforce types. Solutions like Pixid VMS and VectorVMS can play an essential role by providing:

  • Enhanced Workforce Visibility and Analytics: TTA relies on complete visibility across both contingent and permanent workforces. A robust VMS like Pixid VMS consolidates workforce data, enabling organizations to track the movement, cost, and performance of contingent workers alongside permanent staff. By combining insights from multiple talent streams, companies can make more informed decisions about workforce planning and respond more proactively to business needs.
  • Seamless Integration with Other Platforms: A Total Talent model works best when contingent and permanent hiring systems are integrated. Pixid VMS can be linked with Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) and other HR and staffing tools, providing a streamlined experience for hiring managers, suppliers and candidates. This seamless integration supports a cohesive recruitment process that reduces duplication and improves efficiency.
  • Compliance and Risk Management: With increasing regulatory demands, compliance is crucial to the success of TTA. Pixid VMS includes advanced compliance management tools that help organizations adhere to worker classifications, onboarding protocols, and local tax requirements, reducing risk and helping companies adapt to ever-changing regulations.

The Business Case for Total Talent Acquisition

Total Talent Acquisition offers significant strategic advantages for organizations aiming to be more competitive. By consolidating recruitment processes and aligning contingent workforce management with permanent hiring, organizations can access a broader, more versatile talent pool. SIA’s 2023 report highlights several benefits of TTA, including:

  • Cost Savings and Efficiency: Centralized workforce management reduces hiring costs and unlocks economies of scale. A VMS like Pixid VMS supports these cost efficiencies by optimizing workforce mix, simplifying supplier relationships, and minimizing redundant hiring efforts.
  • Access to a Diverse Talent Pool: TTA expands an organization’s reach to include both contingent and permanent workers, ensuring that no talent opportunity is missed. With VMS tools handling contingent workers and ATS platforms supporting permanent recruitment, companies can build comprehensive, searchable talent pools that serve both short- and long-term workforce needs.

Regulatory Challenges and the Role of Compliance in TTA

One of the main challenges of implementing TTA is navigating complex and changing regulations. New rules around worker classification, tax compliance, and contingent staffing in the UK, US, EU and other regions add complexity to contingent workforce management. For example, in the UK, sweeping changes announced in the Employment Rights Bill as well as the new EU Platform Workers Directive and anticipated changes to be introduced by the new US government, could result in an enormously altered landscape for contingent workforce supply and management in many regions, requiring stricter compliance protocols and heightened oversight.

A robust VMS like Pixid’s offers the compliance tools and visibility necessary to meet these requirements, providing essential features for tracking worker classifications, managing onboarding processes, and ensuring tax compliance across jurisdictions. With this support, companies can confidently transition towards TTA while staying compliant with evolving regulatory standards.

Barriers to TTA Adoption and Overcoming Organizational Silos

While the benefits of Total Talent Acquisition are clear, adoption remains low due to barriers such as organizational siloes and lack of consensus. According to SIA, 58% of organizations cite siloes as the main challenge preventing them from fully embracing TTA. Breaking down these barriers requires a unified approach, where procurement and HR teams collaborate to streamline processes and align on shared goals, or where the right technology and expertise can enable a single, unified team to manage the entire workforce supply and management process, either in-house or in conjunction with an external provider of managed services.

Future Trends in TTA and the Importance of Workforce Agility

The renewed interest in TTA is supported by advancements in sourcing technology and workforce analytics, enabling organisations to establish robust, integrated talent pools. A well-implemented VMS helps build a centralized view of all workforce categories and anticipate talent demands, enhancing workforce agility and strategic planning.
As technology continues to evolve, VMS tools like Pixid VMS and VectorVMS will play a crucial role in enabling Total Talent Acquisition, empowering organizations to respond to talent needs with greater flexibility and efficiency.

Conclusion

Adopting Total Talent Acquisition is about more than meeting immediate hiring needs—it’s a strategic approach to building a responsive, future-ready workforce. With powerful VMS tools like Pixid’s, organizations and their staffing suppliers can better bridge the divide between contingent and permanent recruitment, supporting TTA through centralized data, process integration, and enhanced compliance. As companies face skill shortages, regulatory challenges, and increasing demands for workforce agility, TTA provides a compelling model for unifying talent acquisition and workforce management.

If you would like to hear how Pixid’s range of recruitment technology can help enable you to provide a Total Talent Acquisition solution, please feel free to get in touch and we will be happy to discuss.

Contact Us

This website uses cookies.